Smoke test vs. rolling deployment: Choosing a deployment strategy
A smoke test is a quick and simple test that checks if the basic functionalities of a software application are working correctly after a new build or update. On the other hand, rolling deployment is a deployment strategy where updates are gradually rolled out to different parts of a system to minimize downtime and risk. Both smoke tests and rolling deployments aim to ensure the stability and reliability of a software application, but smoke tests focus on functionality while rolling deployments focus on the deployment process itself. Smoke tests are typically performed before a deployment, while rolling deployments are part of the deployment process.
About the smoke test deployment strategy
A smoke test in software deployment is a preliminary test run to check if the basic functionalities of the application are working properly. It is usually done before more comprehensive testing to catch any major issues early on.
By running a smoke test, developers can quickly identify any critical issues that may prevent the application from functioning properly in a live environment. This helps ensure a smoother deployment process and reduces the risk of major failures during production.
Advantages of the smoke test deployment strategy
- Helps quickly identify major issues with the software before proceeding with further testing.
- Saves time and resources by catching critical errors early in the development process.
Disadvantages of the smoke test deployment strategy
- May not uncover all potential issues within the software.
- Can lead to a false sense of security if only surface-level testing is performed.
About the rolling deployment strategy
Rolling deployment is a software deployment strategy where new code is gradually rolled out to a subset of servers or instances in a staggered manner, reducing the risk of downtime or errors affecting all users at once. This approach allows for continuous delivery of updates and features to users while minimizing disruptions to the overall system.
By deploying changes incrementally, rolling deployment enables teams to monitor the impact of new code in real-time and quickly address any issues that arise, ensuring a smoother and more reliable deployment process. This strategy is particularly useful for large-scale applications or services that need to maintain high availability and performance levels during updates.
Advantages of the rolling deployment strategy
- Minimizes downtime: Rolling deployment allows updates to be rolled out gradually across the system, reducing the impact on end users and minimizing downtime.
- Easy rollback: In case of any issues or bugs with the new deployment, rolling deployment allows for an easy rollback to the previous version without affecting the entire system.
Disadvantages of the rolling deployment strategy
- Complexity: Rolling deployment can be more complex to set up and manage compared to other deployment strategies, as it requires careful coordination and monitoring of the rollout process.
- Increased risk: Since updates are being rolled out gradually, there is a risk of inconsistencies in the system if not properly managed, leading to potential issues or bugs affecting some users.
Choosing between smoke test and rolling deployment strategies
| Smoke Test | Rolling Deployment | |
|---|---|---|
| Reliability | Provides a quick initial check to catch major issues before a full deployment. | Gradually deploys changes to smaller subsets of users, allowing for real-time monitoring and rollback if issues arise. |
| Cost | Relatively low cost as it involves minimal resources and time. | May require more resources and planning due to the need for multiple deployments and monitoring. |
| Complexity | Simple and straightforward process. | Requires more coordination and automation to manage the phased deployment process. |
| Speed | Fast initial check to validate changes. | Slower deployment process but reduces the risk of widespread issues. |
The Unleash approach to feature flags
Feature flags enable development teams to manage features in a dynamic, flexible, and controlled manner.
Unleash is a secure, enterprise feature management platform available as open source or as monthly service. Choose your preferred deployment and get started in minutes.
