Smoke test vs. canary release: Choosing a deployment strategy
A smoke test is a preliminary test conducted on a new software build to ensure that the most critical functions are working correctly. On the other hand, a canary release is a technique used in software development where a small subset of users are given access to a new feature or update before it is rolled out to the entire user base. Both smoke tests and canary releases help to identify potential issues early on in the development process, but the main difference lies in their scope – smoke tests focus on overall functionality, while canary releases focus on user experience and feedback. Additionally, smoke tests are typically automated and performed by developers, while canary releases involve real users providing feedback.
About the smoke test deployment strategy
A smoke test in software deployment is a preliminary test run to check if the basic functionalities of the application are working properly. It is usually done before more comprehensive testing to catch any major issues early on.
By running a smoke test, developers can quickly identify any critical issues that may prevent the application from functioning properly in a live environment. This helps ensure a smoother deployment process and reduces the risk of major failures during production.
Advantages of the smoke test deployment strategy
- Helps quickly identify major issues with the software before proceeding with further testing.
- Saves time and resources by catching critical errors early in the development process.
Disadvantages of the smoke test deployment strategy
- May not uncover all potential issues within the software.
- Can lead to a false sense of security if only surface-level testing is performed.
About the canary release deployment strategy
Canary release is a deployment strategy in software development where a new version of a software application is gradually rolled out to a small subset of users before being released to the entire user base. This allows developers to monitor the performance and gather feedback on the new version before fully deploying it, reducing the risk of widespread issues.
Advantages of the canary release deployment strategy
- Allows for early detection of issues: By rolling out changes to a small subset of users first, any potential bugs or performance issues can be identified and addressed before a full release.
- Minimizes risk: Canary releases help mitigate the risk of deploying changes that could have a negative impact on all users by gradually rolling out updates and monitoring their impact.
Disadvantages of the canary release deployment strategy
- Increased complexity: Managing multiple versions of the software running concurrently can add complexity to the deployment process and require additional resources to monitor and maintain.
- Limited sample size: Depending on the size of the canary group, the feedback collected may not be representative of the overall user base, potentially leading to issues being missed before a full release.
Choosing between smoke test and canary release strategies
| Smoke Test | Canary Release | |
|---|---|---|
| Reliability | Provides a quick check to ensure basic functionalities are working. | Gradually exposes a new feature to a small subset of users to catch potential issues early. |
| Cost | Relatively low cost as it is a simple and quick test. | Can be costly due to the need for separate infrastructure and monitoring for the canary group. |
| Complexity | Simple to set up and execute. | Requires careful planning and monitoring to ensure a smooth rollout. |
| Speed | Quick to execute and provides immediate feedback. | Gradual release may take longer but allows for more thorough testing before full deployment. |
The Unleash approach to feature flags
Feature flags enable development teams to manage features in a dynamic, flexible, and controlled manner.
Unleash is a secure, enterprise feature management platform available as open source or as monthly service. Choose your preferred deployment and get started in minutes.
