Smoke test vs. blue-green: Choosing a deployment strategy
A smoke test is a preliminary test run on a software build to ensure that basic functionalities are working correctly. Blue-green deployment is a deployment strategy where two identical production environments, one “blue” and one “green,” are alternately used for production and testing to minimize downtime during updates. Both smoke testing and blue-green deployment are used to minimize risks and ensure smooth deployment processes, but while smoke testing focuses on functionality, blue-green deployment focuses on minimizing downtime and ensuring a seamless transition between versions.
About the smoke test deployment strategy
A smoke test in software deployment is a preliminary test run to check if the basic functionalities of the application are working properly. It is usually done before more comprehensive testing to catch any major issues early on.
By running a smoke test, developers can quickly identify any critical issues that may prevent the application from functioning properly in a live environment. This helps ensure a smoother deployment process and reduces the risk of major failures during production.
Advantages of the smoke test deployment strategy
- Helps quickly identify major issues with the software before proceeding with further testing.
- Saves time and resources by catching critical errors early in the development process.
Disadvantages of the smoke test deployment strategy
- May not uncover all potential issues within the software.
- Can lead to a false sense of security if only surface-level testing is performed.
About the blue-green deployment strategy
Blue-green deployment is a software deployment strategy where two identical production environments, blue and green, are maintained simultaneously. This allows for seamless updates and rollbacks without downtime, as traffic can be switched between the two environments.
In this strategy, updates are first deployed to the green environment while the blue environment continues to handle production traffic. Once the green environment is verified to be functioning correctly, traffic is switched to it, making it the new production environment. This approach minimizes risk and ensures a smooth deployment process.
Advantages of the blue-green deployment strategy
- Reduces downtime: Blue-green deployment allows for seamless updates or rollbacks without impacting users, minimizing downtime during the deployment process.
- Enables easy testing: Developers can easily test new features or updates in a production-like environment before switching traffic to the new version, ensuring a smooth transition.
Cons of the blue-green deployment strategy
- Increased infrastructure costs: Maintaining duplicate environments for blue-green deployment can lead to higher infrastructure costs, especially for larger applications.
- Complexity in managing multiple environments: Managing two separate environments can introduce complexity in configuration management and monitoring, requiring additional effort and resources.
Choosing between smoke test and blue-green strategies
| Smoke Test | Blue-Green Deployment | |
|---|---|---|
| Reliability | Quick check to ensure basic functionality is working. | Full duplicate environment ensures minimal downtime and rollback capabilities. |
| Cost | Low cost as it only tests basic functionality. | Higher cost due to maintaining duplicate environments. |
| Complexity | Simple to set up and execute. | More complex setup due to managing multiple environments simultaneously. |
| Speed | Fast execution as it only tests basic functionality. | Slower deployment due to switching traffic between environments. |
The Unleash approach to feature flags
Feature flags enable development teams to manage features in a dynamic, flexible, and controlled manner.
Unleash is a secure, enterprise feature management platform available as open source or as monthly service. Choose your preferred deployment and get started in minutes.
