Canary release vs kill switch: Choosing a deployment strategy

March 27, 2024

Article by Michael Ferranti

Canary release

Canary release is a deployment strategy where a new version of an application is gradually rolled out to a small subset of users before being made available to the entire user base. This approach allows teams to test the new version in a production environment with real users, while limiting the potential impact of any issues or bugs. The subset of users experiencing the new version serves as the “canary in the coal mine,” providing early warning signals of problems.

By monitoring the performance and user experience of the canary release, development teams can gather valuable data and feedback before committing to a full deployment. If issues arise, the release can be quickly rolled back, affecting only the small percentage of users in the canary group. If the release performs well, the deployment can gradually scale to larger groups until it reaches 100% of users, ensuring a smoother transition to the new version.

Kill switch

A kill switch is a deployment strategy that provides an emergency mechanism to quickly disable specific functionality or revert to a previous state when critical issues are detected. It acts as a safety net that allows teams to respond rapidly to unexpected problems in production without requiring a complete rollback or redeployment of the application.

Kill switches are designed to be simple, reliable, and accessible to both technical and non-technical stakeholders. They can be implemented at various levels of granularity, from disabling specific features to shutting down entire services. This strategy is particularly valuable in high-stakes environments where downtime or malfunctions could have significant business, security, or safety implications.

Comparison: Canary release vs. kill switch

Purpose

Canary Release: Tests new functionality with a subset of users to identify issues before full deployment.

Kill Switch: Provides emergency rollback capability to quickly respond to production issues.

Timing

Canary Release: Proactive approach implemented before wide release to prevent widespread issues.

Kill Switch: Reactive approach activated after issues are detected to mitigate impact.

Scope

Canary Release: Typically applies to an entire application version or significant feature set.

Kill Switch: Can be granular, targeting specific features or components causing problems.

User impact

Canary Release: Affects only a small, predetermined percentage of users during testing.

Kill Switch: Can affect all users of a feature when activated, but prevents more serious consequences.

Complexity

Canary Release: Requires infrastructure for traffic splitting and detailed monitoring.

Kill Switch: Relatively simpler to implement, focusing on reliable on/off mechanisms.

Duration

Canary Release: Planned process that typically spans hours to days as rollout progresses.

Kill Switch: Emergency measure that can be activated in seconds and may remain in place until a proper fix is deployed.

Feature flags with canary release

Feature flags integrate seamlessly with canary releases by providing the infrastructure to control which users see new features. During a canary deployment, feature flags can be configured to expose the new functionality to only a specific percentage of users or a defined cohort. This granular control allows teams to progressively increase exposure based on real-time feedback and metrics, ensuring a smoother rollout process. The flags also enable quick toggling between versions if issues arise, without requiring code changes or redeployments.

For canary releases, feature flags often incorporate sophisticated targeting rules that consider user attributes, geography, or usage patterns. Teams can use these targeting capabilities to test features with representative user segments before wider release. Additionally, feature flags can be connected to automated monitoring systems that watch for key performance indicators or error rates, automatically rolling back the canary if predefined thresholds are exceeded. This automation increases safety while reducing the operational burden on development and operations teams.

Feature flags with kill switches

When implementing kill switches, feature flags serve as the underlying technical mechanism that enables the immediate disabling of functionality. The kill switch essentially operates as a special type of feature flag with a binary state (on/off) that’s accessible through a simplified interface designed for emergency situations. These feature flags are typically configured with appropriate default fallback behaviors that trigger when the switch is activated, ensuring the system degrades gracefully rather than failing completely.

With kill switches, feature flag configurations often include special access controls and audit trails to manage who can activate the emergency measures and track when they’ve been used. Unlike regular feature flags that might be adjusted frequently for experimentation, kill switch flags are designed for stability and reliability during critical situations. Teams typically implement additional safeguards around these flags, such as confirmation steps before activation, automated notifications to stakeholders when triggered, and dashboards that highlight which emergency switches are currently active across the system.

Canary release and kill switch are both deployment strategies that help mitigate risks, but they serve different purposes. Canary releases gradually roll out changes to a small subset of users before a full deployment, allowing teams to test in production with minimal risk. This approach enables real-world validation, early detection of issues, and the ability to gather user feedback while limiting potential damage. However, canary releases require more complex infrastructure, increase deployment time, and may create temporary inconsistencies in user experience. They also demand sophisticated monitoring and metrics to accurately assess the impact of the new version.

Kill switches, on the other hand, provide an emergency mechanism to rapidly disable specific features or roll back to a previous state when critical issues arise. This approach offers immediate risk mitigation, simplicity in implementation, and works well for features with clear isolation boundaries. However, kill switches are reactive rather than preventative, may not address data corruption that occurred before activation, and require careful design to avoid cascading failures. Choose canary releases when introducing substantial changes that benefit from gradual validation and when your infrastructure supports incremental traffic shifting. Opt for kill switches when you need a safety net for critical features, during high-risk deployments, or when immediate system recovery is essential for maintaining service availability.

Frequently asked questions

What is a canary release?

A canary release is a deployment strategy where a new version of an application is gradually rolled out to a small subset of users before being made available to the entire user base. This approach allows teams to test the new version in a production environment with real users, while limiting the potential impact of any issues or bugs. The subset of users experiencing the new version serves as the “canary in the coal mine,” providing early warning signals of problems.

What are the benefits of using a canary release?

Canary releases allow development teams to gather valuable data and feedback before committing to a full deployment. If issues arise, the release can be quickly rolled back, affecting only the small percentage of users in the canary group. If the release performs well, the deployment can gradually scale to larger groups until it reaches 100% of users, ensuring a smoother transition to the new version.

What is a kill switch?

How do canary releases and kill switches differ in purpose?

Canary releases test new functionality with a subset of users to identify issues before full deployment, making them a proactive approach. Kill switches provide emergency rollback capability to quickly respond to production issues, making them a reactive approach that’s activated after issues are detected to mitigate impact.

How do feature flags work with canary releases?

Feature flags integrate with canary releases by providing the infrastructure to control which users see new features. During a canary deployment, feature flags can be configured to expose new functionality to only a specific percentage of users or a defined cohort. This granular control allows teams to progressively increase exposure based on real-time feedback and metrics, ensuring a smoother rollout process.

How do feature flags work with kill switches?

With kill switches, feature flags serve as the underlying technical mechanism that enables the immediate disabling of functionality. The kill switch operates as a special type of feature flag with a binary state (on/off) that’s accessible through a simplified interface designed for emergency situations. These feature flags are typically configured with appropriate default fallback behaviors that trigger when the switch is activated, ensuring the system degrades gracefully.

Share this article